When roofing fails, moisture penetration results. If overlooked, water infiltration can lead to costly wood rot, and unhealthy mold and mildew growth in your home. Two of the most common roofing materials for homes in the Kansas City area are Asphalt Shingles and Metal Roofing. We want to help you decide which of these would be the best choice for your roof replacement.
There are significant differences between these two roofing material types. The product you choose will directly impact:
- The look of your roof
- The weight of your roof
- How damage resistant your roof is
- How long your roof will last
Cost Comparison
Asphalt Shingle Cost
*All cost ranges listed here are general estimates only. Contact Christian Brothers Roofing to get a price estimate for your roof replacement.
Asphalt roofing installation costs between $10,000 and $15,000*, and most homeowners choose this roofing material for three reasons:
- It’s cost-effective
- It’s easy to install
- It’s simple to repair
Asphalt shingles are an entry-level product, while lifetime shingles are a more substantial product with an increased cost.
Metal Roofing Cost
Metal roofing is growing in popularity due to its strong energy efficiency and cooling ability. Installing a metal roof will cost more than an asphalt shingle roof, but will last longer too. Choosing Decra stone-coated steel roofing will increase your cost by around 240%*. Standing seam comes in even higher around a 300%* cost increase. If you’re looking for barn metal or agricultural metal, you can gauge a little less of an increase at around 180%* above the cost of asphalt shingles.<
Standing Seam Metal Roofing
The cost of standing seam panels can be up to 300%* more than asphalt costs, although it has great benefits too, like unexposed fasteners. This means they aren’t exposed to UV, moisture, wind, and other elements, extending the longevity of your roof. However, the cost to install these roofs greatly increases.
As it’s difficult to grip the shiny material, standing seam roofs are hard to install and can be more dangerous than other types. For this reason alone, you definitely want to hire a professional to install your roof.
Stone Coated Steel Roofing
A knowledgeable roofing professional will choose a top product like Decra. Decra Stone Coated Steel roofing is most known for its lifetime interlocking system, which has the highest wind speed rate across all products. These interlocked panels lock into each other to prevent any exposure or pulling during high winds, making it ideal for the midwest and Kansas City area during tornado season. For these reasons, stone-coated steel can cost up to 240%* more, which means it’s ideal for “forever” or luxury homes.
Lifespan
Metal roofing
This durable roofing material can last over 50 years, creating a great value for homeowners. Homeowners often choose this roofing for their “forever” or luxury homes.
- Increased energy efficiency—Metal roofing helps you save up to 40% on your utilities.
- Lower cooling costs—The reflective styles of metal roofing keep your home cooler each summer, saving you on your air conditioning.
- Decreased greenhouse gases—Some styles of metal roofing decrease hot temperatures and greenhouse gases.
- Environmentally friendly—Can be made from recycled materials and recycled when it’s lifespan is over.
Asphalt roofing
—This popular roofing material usually lasts 15-30 years before it needs to be replaced. Whether you are planning to live in your home for years to come or are looking to re-roof your home before putting it on the market, this is a good choice and most popular choice among all homeowners.
Warranty Coverage
Both Asphalt and Metal Roofing come with excellent warranty coverage.
The manufacturer’s warranty should cover the roofing material, and the contractor should cover installation. Understand there is a difference between a standard roof warranty vs. an extended or no-dollar-limit (NDL) warranty backed by the manufacturer. Additional inspections are required for greater warranty coverage and give you confidence in your investment.
Trusted Residential and Commercial Roofing Installation
Get a long-lasting roof from a trusted, local roofing contractor. Christian Brothers Roofing is a highly certified Kansas City roofing company. See our home roof installation services, and if you are looking for a roof replacement, our team can advise you on the best options. Simply schedule a consultation today.
